fix(core): sync review round 1: lists, supersede, dedupe conflicts, retries

- dedupe files conflicts for disagreeing fields instead of dropping them
- merged-away records never file removals
- matched work committed before apply so retries reuse it (no draft leaks)
- stale pending events superseded by newer values
- multi-source engagement removal only detaches the source
- list records applied with history-derived ownership
- gone targets resolve as ignored; counts only for committed records

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
This commit is contained in:
Lucas Winther
2026-10-30 20:43:08 +01:00
co-authored by Claude Opus 5.5
parent 0604c323c3
commit a003c3eb7d
8 changed files with 675 additions and 196 deletions
+94 -75
View File
@@ -1,14 +1,16 @@
import type { Db } from "@sttracker/db/db";
import { nowIso } from "@sttracker/db/ids";
import { fromJson } from "@sttracker/db/json";
import { fromJson, toJson } from "@sttracker/db/json";
import type { ChangeStatus, ChangeType, Database } from "@sttracker/db/schema";
import type { WorkHint } from "@sttracker/plugin-sdk/types";
import { type EngagementPatch, softDeleteEngagement, updateEngagement } from "../engagements.ts";
import { type EntryPatch, moveEntryToWork, softDeleteEntry, upsertEntry } from "../entries.ts";
import { NotFoundError, ValidationError } from "../errors.ts";
import type { Actor, Executor } from "../history.ts";
import { softDeleteList } from "../lists.ts";
import { matchWork } from "../matching.ts";
import { engagementValues, entryValues } from "./apply.ts";
import { resolveAliasIn } from "../works.ts";
import { applyPatch, engagementValues, entryValues } from "./apply.ts";
import { decodeVersion } from "./snapshot.ts";
export interface ChangeEvent {
@@ -65,10 +67,12 @@ const STATUS_FOR = { accept: "accepted", ignore: "ignored", keep_mine: "kept_min
/**
* Resolve a pending event.
* - `accept`: changed/conflict applies the incoming value as the event's plugin actor (which then owns
* the field); removed soft-deletes the target; merged moves the entry to the merge target's work.
* the field); removed soft-deletes the target (an engagement other sources still report only loses
* this connection's `engagement_sources` row); merged moves the entry to the merge target's work.
* - `keep_mine`: changed/conflict set `field_sources[field] = "user"`, so that source stops overriding it.
* - `ignore`: data untouched.
* All three set `status` and `resolved_at`.
* All three set `status` and `resolved_at`. Accept/keep_mine on a target that is gone (deleted, or merged
* away with no live survivor) resolves the event as `ignored` with `payload.reason = "target_gone"`.
*/
export async function resolveChange(
db: Db,
@@ -76,7 +80,7 @@ export async function resolveChange(
changeId: string,
action: "accept" | "ignore" | "keep_mine",
): Promise<void> {
if (!(action in STATUS_FOR)) throw new ValidationError("action", "invalid");
if (!Object.hasOwn(STATUS_FOR, action)) throw new ValidationError("action", "invalid");
const row = await db.k.selectFrom("change_events").selectAll().where("id", "=", changeId).where("user_id", "=", userId).executeTakeFirst();
if (!row) throw new NotFoundError("change");
if (row.status !== "pending") throw new ValidationError("status", "not_pending");
@@ -96,19 +100,26 @@ export async function resolveChange(
.executeTakeFirst();
if (Number(claimed.numUpdatedRows) === 0) throw new ValidationError("status", "not_pending");
if (action === "ignore") return;
if (ev.type === "changed" || ev.type === "conflict") {
const field = String(ev.payload.field);
if (action === "accept") {
const value = ev.type === "conflict" ? ev.payload.incoming : ev.payload.to;
await setField(db, tx, userId, ev, field, value, actor);
} else {
await setField(db, tx, userId, ev, field, undefined, "user");
}
const isField = ev.type === "changed" || ev.type === "conflict";
if (action === "keep_mine" && !isField) return;
const targetId = await liveTargetId(tx, userId, ev);
if (!targetId) {
await tx
.updateTable("change_events")
.set({ status: "ignored", payload: toJson({ ...ev.payload, reason: "target_gone" }) })
.where("id", "=", ev.id)
.execute();
return;
}
if (action !== "accept") return;
if (ev.type === "removed") return removeTarget(db, tx, userId, ev, actor);
if (ev.type === "merged" && mergeTarget) return moveTo(db, tx, userId, ev, mergeTarget, actor);
if (isField) {
const field = String(ev.payload.field);
const value = action === "keep_mine" ? undefined : ev.type === "conflict" ? ev.payload.incoming : ev.payload.to;
await setField(db, tx, userId, ev.targetEntity, targetId, field, value, action === "keep_mine" ? "user" : actor);
return;
}
if (ev.type === "removed") return removeTarget(db, tx, userId, ev, targetId, actor);
if (ev.type === "merged" && mergeTarget) return moveTo(db, tx, userId, targetId, mergeTarget, actor);
});
}
@@ -118,51 +129,29 @@ async function actorFor(db: Db, connectionId: string | null): Promise<Actor> {
return c ? `plugin:${c.plugin_id}:${c.id}` : "user";
}
/** Write `value` to the target's field as `actor`; with `value` undefined, re-stamp the current value. */
async function setField(db: Db, k: Executor, userId: string, ev: ChangeEvent, field: string, value: unknown, actor: Actor): Promise<void> {
if (!ev.targetId) throw new NotFoundError(ev.targetEntity);
/**
* The event's target if it is still live. A soft-deleted entry that was merged into another (the user's
* work alias leads to a work with a live entry) resolves to that survivor. Otherwise null.
*/
async function liveTargetId(k: Executor, userId: string, ev: ChangeEvent): Promise<string | null> {
if (!ev.targetId) return null;
if (ev.targetEntity === "entry") {
const r = await k
const r = await k.selectFrom("entries").select(["id", "work_id", "deleted_at"]).where("id", "=", ev.targetId).where("user_id", "=", userId).executeTakeFirst();
if (!r) return null;
if (r.deleted_at === null) return r.id;
const to = await resolveAliasIn(k, userId, r.work_id);
if (to === r.work_id) return null;
const survivor = await k
.selectFrom("entries")
.selectAll()
.where("id", "=", ev.targetId)
.select("id")
.where("user_id", "=", userId)
.where("work_id", "=", to)
.where("deleted_at", "is", null)
.executeTakeFirst();
if (!r) throw new NotFoundError("entry");
const v = value === undefined ? entryValues(r)[field] : value;
await upsertEntry(db, userId, r.work_id, { [field]: v } as Partial<EntryPatch>, actor, k);
return;
return survivor?.id ?? null;
}
if (ev.targetEntity === "engagement") {
const r = await k
.selectFrom("engagements as g")
.innerJoin("entries as e", "e.id", "g.entry_id")
.selectAll("g")
.where("g.id", "=", ev.targetId)
.where("e.user_id", "=", userId)
.executeTakeFirst();
if (!r) throw new NotFoundError("engagement");
const v = value === undefined ? engagementValues(r)[field] : value;
await updateEngagement(db, userId, r.id, { [field]: v } as Partial<EngagementPatch>, actor, k);
return;
}
throw new ValidationError("targetEntity", "unsupported");
}
async function removeTarget(db: Db, k: Executor, userId: string, ev: ChangeEvent, actor: Actor): Promise<void> {
if (!ev.targetId) return;
if (ev.targetEntity === "entry") {
const live = await k
.selectFrom("entries")
.select("id")
.where("id", "=", ev.targetId)
.where("user_id", "=", userId)
.where("deleted_at", "is", null)
.executeTakeFirst();
if (live) await softDeleteEntry(db, userId, live.id, actor, k);
} else if (ev.targetEntity === "engagement") {
const live = await k
.selectFrom("engagements as g")
.innerJoin("entries as e", "e.id", "g.entry_id")
.select("g.id")
@@ -171,7 +160,51 @@ async function removeTarget(db: Db, k: Executor, userId: string, ev: ChangeEvent
.where("g.deleted_at", "is", null)
.where("e.deleted_at", "is", null)
.executeTakeFirst();
if (live) await softDeleteEngagement(db, userId, live.id, actor, k);
return r?.id ?? null;
}
if (ev.targetEntity === "list") {
const r = await k
.selectFrom("lists")
.select("id")
.where("id", "=", ev.targetId)
.where("user_id", "=", userId)
.where("deleted_at", "is", null)
.executeTakeFirst();
return r?.id ?? null;
}
return null;
}
/** Write `value` to a live target's field as `actor`; with `value` undefined, re-stamp the current value. */
async function setField(db: Db, k: Executor, userId: string, entity: string, id: string, field: string, value: unknown, actor: Actor): Promise<void> {
if (entity === "entry") {
const r = await k.selectFrom("entries").selectAll().where("id", "=", id).executeTakeFirstOrThrow();
const v = value === undefined ? entryValues(r)[field] : value;
await upsertEntry(db, userId, r.work_id, { [field]: v } as Partial<EntryPatch>, actor, k);
} else if (entity === "engagement") {
const r = await k.selectFrom("engagements").selectAll().where("id", "=", id).executeTakeFirstOrThrow();
const v = value === undefined ? engagementValues(r)[field] : value;
await updateEngagement(db, userId, id, { [field]: v } as Partial<EngagementPatch>, actor, k);
} else if (entity === "list") {
// Lists have no field_sources: ownership comes from history, so keep_mine needs no write.
if (value === undefined) return;
await applyPatch(k, db, userId, { entity: "list", id }, { [field]: value }, actor);
} else {
throw new ValidationError("targetEntity", "unsupported");
}
}
async function removeTarget(db: Db, k: Executor, userId: string, ev: ChangeEvent, targetId: string, actor: Actor): Promise<void> {
if (ev.targetEntity === "entry") return softDeleteEntry(db, userId, targetId, actor, k);
if (ev.targetEntity === "list") return softDeleteList(db, userId, targetId, actor, k);
if (ev.targetEntity === "engagement") {
// The same play may still be reported by other sources: detach this one, delete only when none remain.
if (ev.connectionId) {
await k.deleteFrom("engagement_sources").where("engagement_id", "=", targetId).where("connection_id", "=", ev.connectionId).execute();
}
const left = await k.selectFrom("engagement_sources").select("id").where("engagement_id", "=", targetId).executeTakeFirst();
if (left) return;
await softDeleteEngagement(db, userId, targetId, actor, k);
}
}
@@ -191,7 +224,9 @@ async function mergeTargetWork(db: Db, userId: string, ev: ChangeEvent, actor: A
.where("key", "=", intoKey)
.executeTakeFirst();
if (!target) throw new ValidationError("intoKey", "unknown_record");
if (target.target_id) {
// A record matched but not yet applied stores its work directly.
if (target.target_entity === "work" && target.target_id) return target.target_id;
if (target.target_id && (target.target_entity === "entry" || target.target_entity === "engagement")) {
const entryId =
target.target_entity === "entry"
? target.target_id
@@ -214,25 +249,9 @@ async function mergeTargetWork(db: Db, userId: string, ev: ChangeEvent, actor: A
return (await matchWork(db, userId, hint, actor)).workId;
}
async function moveTo(db: Db, k: Executor, userId: string, ev: ChangeEvent, workId: string, actor: Actor): Promise<void> {
if (!ev.targetId) return;
const entry = await k
.selectFrom("entries")
.select(["id", "work_id"])
.where("id", "=", ev.targetId)
.where("user_id", "=", userId)
.where("deleted_at", "is", null)
.executeTakeFirst();
if (!entry) throw new NotFoundError("entry");
/** Move the live entry to the work; `moveEntryToWork` re-points source records if it merges. */
async function moveTo(db: Db, k: Executor, userId: string, entryId: string, workId: string, actor: Actor): Promise<void> {
const entry = await k.selectFrom("entries").select("work_id").where("id", "=", entryId).executeTakeFirstOrThrow();
if (entry.work_id === workId) return;
const result = await moveEntryToWork(db, userId, entry.id, workId, actor, k);
if (result.id !== entry.id) {
// The entry merged into an existing one: records that mapped to it now map to the survivor.
await k
.updateTable("source_records")
.set({ target_id: result.id })
.where("target_entity", "=", "entry")
.where("target_id", "=", entry.id)
.execute();
}
await moveEntryToWork(db, userId, entryId, workId, actor, k);
}