Files
budget2.0/docs/ARCHITECTURE.md
T
Lucas WintherandClaude Opus 5 8d2b2ca881 feat(money): one decimals setting for the dataset, not one per currency
`Settings.digits` replaces `CurrencyDef.digits`. Every amount rounds to it,
whatever its currency, and `digitsFor` is gone: the sixteen call sites read the
setting, and the domain functions that took a currency table purely to look
digits up take a `digits: number` instead. Schema 6.

The owner asked for this with the cost in front of them, and the cost is real:
a dataset mixing minor units cannot be described any more. Yen at 0 beside
kroner at 2 has no correct global value — 2 gives ¥1234.56, an amount yen
cannot represent; 0 rounds 49.95 DKK to 50 and drifts the carry from the bank.
Nothing in the app warns. docs/specs/2026-09-02-global-decimals-design.md
argues it in full, including what re-adding a per-currency override would take,
and AGENTS.md §1 now says not to reintroduce one without revisiting the
decision.

The 5 -> 6 step takes the MAXIMUM of the per-currency digits, not the base
currency's. A dataset holding a three-decimal currency already has
three-decimal amounts in it, and adopting the base's 2 would truncate the next
edit of one; the maximum can only keep more precision, never less. On every
dataset this app has written all four currencies record 2, so nothing rounds
differently than before.

Changing the setting does not rewrite stored amounts. 49.95 stays 49.95 and
shows as 50; totals recompute at the new precision. Rewriting each Money is a
destructive whole-dataset write, which §1 owes a backup export first, and it is
lossy one way.

Display turned out to be the hole in the plan. src/ui/format.ts pinned
minimumFractionDigits: 2 in a module-level Intl.NumberFormat, so it never read
the dataset at all — equally broken under per-currency digits, where a JPY
rendered "3,333.00", so a pre-existing gap rather than a regression. Shipping a
Settings control that display ignores would look broken at 0 and be lossy at 3,
hiding precision the dataset holds. So format.ts takes digits like roundMoney
does, useMoneyFormat() binds them for the 64 call sites, and postRowCells takes
the formatter as an argument because it is a plain helper, not a component.

currencyDigits.test.ts is rewritten rather than deleted. Driving a dataset at
ZERO decimals through rounding, both FX directions, both split modes, plan
division, the fold and the month view still tells a real implementation from
one assuming 2 — it just cannot prove per-currency flow, because there is none.
It also asserts that raising the setting to 2 changes what the fold produces.

Verified in Chrome, not only in tests: a v5 dataset with digits 2/0/3 written
straight into IndexedDB migrates to a setting of 3, the table loses its
Decimals column, and editing the control persists schema 6 with digits stripped
from each currency and income left at 20000.55. The same month reads 600/206 at
zero decimals and 600.000/205.561 at three, so the figures recompute rather
than merely reformat.

Not verified here: the .ods in a real spreadsheet.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <[email protected]>
2026-09-03 03:12:14 +02:00

199 lines
9.6 KiB
Markdown
Executable File
Raw Blame History

This file contains ambiguous Unicode characters
This file contains Unicode characters that might be confused with other characters. If you think that this is intentional, you can safely ignore this warning. Use the Escape button to reveal them.
# Architecture
Orientation for anyone — human or agent — changing this codebase. It explains
where things live and, more usefully, *why* several non-obvious choices are the
way they are. Most of them were paid for with a bug.
## Shape
A personal budgeting PWA. No backend. IndexedDB in the owner's browser is the
only copy of their data. One static artifact deploys to both GitHub Pages (under
a subpath) and a self-hosted Docker image.
Bun is the runtime, package manager, bundler and test runner. React 19,
Tailwind 4, shadcn/ui. No Vite, no npm, no jest.
## Layers
```
src/domain/ pure. no React, no IndexedDB, no clock. testable with no DOM.
src/store/ persistence, mutations, and the ONLY place a clock is read.
src/export/ JSON and ODS generation. pure.
src/ui/ React. reads through hooks, writes through store actions.
build.ts static build: publicPath, hashed names, SW precache, 404.html.
server.ts the Docker image's static file server.
```
The dependency rule is one-directional: `ui -> store -> domain`. `domain` imports
nothing from the others; `store` never imports from `ui`.
`src/domain/smoke.test.ts` asserts the domain is importable with no DOM. That is
why happy-dom is registered **per test file** rather than as a global bunfig
preload — a global DOM would make that assertion vacuously true and silently
retire the check.
## The fold is the single source of every number
`src/domain/fold.ts` holds the one implementation of envelope rollover:
```
remaining = carriedIn + allocation − charges (carried forward, monthly)
```
Unspent carries; overspend carries as debt. **Nothing else may recompute this.**
The month view, year matrix, summary, per-post views and the ODS export all
aggregate over `foldBalances` / `figuresFor`. A closing balance is read from
`byMonth[11].remaining`, never re-summed.
If you find yourself writing `carriedIn + allocation - charges` outside
`fold.ts`, that is the invariant breaking. It matters because two screens
silently disagreeing about someone's money is the worst failure this app has.
Editing any past month recomputes everything after it. That is correct: the fold
is a left fold, and history is causal.
## Data flow for a single edit
```
onChange
└─ capture event.target.value into a const ← synchronously, see Gotchas
└─ store.mutate(draft => action(draft))
└─ serialization queue (one mutation at a time)
└─ structuredClone(snapshot) → apply → await persistence.write()
└─ snapshot = next; notify()
└─ useSyncExternalStore re-renders
```
Three deliberate properties in that chain:
- **Write before the snapshot moves.** If the write fails, the UI keeps showing
the last *saved* state, and `useMutate` surfaces the rejection. The user is
never shown data that was not persisted.
- **Serialized.** Two edits inside one write window would otherwise both clone
the same base and the later commit would silently drop the earlier one.
- **Cloned.** `useSyncExternalStore` detects change by reference identity;
mutating in place makes the UI silently stop re-rendering.
The two whole-dataset writes take the same queue and the same rules:
`store.replace()` behind JSON import, and `store.reset()` behind Settings'
"Reset everything". `reset()` calls the same `createSeedDataset` that `load()`
uses on a first run, so "reset" and "a brand-new browser" cannot drift apart.
Both are preceded in the UI by a JSON backup download that must succeed before
the destructive write is attempted.
## Money
A float, deliberately, with two rules that make it safe:
1. **Round at every boundary** via `roundMoney` — after any division, after any
FX conversion, and at the `src/store/actions.ts` mutation boundary. The UI
adds no rounding of its own.
2. **Never round the last distributed part independently.** Compute it as
`total − sum(others)` so the parts sum exactly to the whole. `withRemainder`
in `money.ts` is the only place that logic lives.
**`FxRate.baseUnitsPerOne` is never rounded.** Rates are stored at six decimals
and are not money; quantizing one to cents is wrong in kind.
**Decimal places are data, not a constant — one value for the whole dataset.**
`Settings.digits` is what every amount rounds to, whatever its currency;
`Dataset.currencies` records only a code, name and symbol. `roundMoney` takes a
digit count and every call site reads that setting, required rather than
defaulted, so a missed site is a compile error instead of something that works
while the setting is 2 and breaks the moment it is not.
`src/domain/currencyDigits.test.ts` drives a dataset at zero decimals through
the whole stack, which is the only test that can tell a real implementation
from one that assumes 2.
The cost is explicit: a dataset mixing minor units — yen at 0 beside kroner at
2 — cannot be described, and nothing in the app will warn about it. That was
the owner's call, argued in full in
[`specs/2026-09-02-global-decimals-design.md`](specs/2026-09-02-global-decimals-design.md),
which also says what re-adding a per-currency override would take.
## Splits and finance plans compose
A purchase can be split across posts *and* spread over months at once. The trick
is in `charges.ts`: first compute how the **whole** purchase divides across posts
(`splitPartsOfTotal`), then distribute each month's slice proportionally *to
those parts*. Both split modes collapse to one code path per slice.
Applying a split's raw value per-slice looks simpler and passes every percentage
test — and charges a fixed "2000 to Video Games" in full on every slice.
## Things the app deliberately does NOT validate
Adding a "missing" guard here is a regression, not a fix:
- going over budget, ever, anywhere;
- allocation percentages summing past 100%;
- splits that do not sum to the total (the remainder-absorbing split reconciles
them by design);
- negative amounts (a refund is a normal line).
## Gotchas paid for with real bugs
`AGENTS.md` §2 carries the enforceable one-line form of these, with the test
that fails when each reappears. What follows is the *mechanism* behind them,
which is the part worth reading once.
- **Never read `event.target.value` inside a `mutate()` callback.** `mutate`
defers behind the queue and a write; React resets a controlled input's DOM
value long before the callback runs, so you read the *old* value and commit
it. This froze the income field at 0. `src/ui/eventCapture.test.ts` fails the
build if it reappears.
- **Read `process.env.BUN_PUBLIC_*` through a `try/catch` accessor.** Bun only
inlines the literal when the variable is *set*; unset, the reference survives
into the browser bundle and throws `ReferenceError: process is not defined`
before the app boots. A `typeof process` guard does NOT work — after inlining
it still runs in the browser and discards the inlined value, silently breaking
subpath deploys. See `readBasePathEnv` in `src/ui/basePath.ts`.
- **Do not define a bare `--accent` CSS variable.** shadcn owns it as a
near-white hover *background* paired with near-black text; overriding it drops
hover contrast below WCAG AA app-wide. Project tokens are namespaced
`--budget-*`.
- **`sw.js` must stay unhashed and be served `no-cache`.** A cached or hashed
service worker can never be replaced, pinning users to an old build forever.
- **A React error boundary does not catch throws from event handlers.** Domain
functions that throw (`MissingRateError`, `remainderIndexOf`, `monthOf`,
`equalSlices`) must be guarded at the call site when called from a handler.
## Testing, and its limits
Most logic is pure and tested directly with `bun test`. The domain carries the
bulk of the coverage; the UI is thin by design.
**A browser IS available**, via `scripts/screenshot.ts` — headless Chrome
driven over CDP, because Chrome's own `--screenshot` fires on the load event
and captures an empty page before this app's async IndexedDB read resolves.
That script is how the month view, the carry meter and the rule editors were
first seen by anyone. It reports console errors too, which is the point: a page
that renders blank because of a thrown error looks identical to an empty one.
Its limits are real. The container's fontconfig maps every generic family to a
monospace face, so screenshots need a `FONTCONFIG_FILE` override to be
representative; Chrome starts with an empty profile each run; and no screenshot
can judge how a design feels. Real offline behaviour, the install and update
prompts, and the `.ods` opening in a spreadsheet remain unverifiable here.
Where a check could not be run, the honest substitute was used and recorded —
the `.ods` is validated structurally by unzipping it and asserting `mimetype`
is first and stored, every XML part parses, and numeric cells carry
`office:value`.
`src/ui/eventCapture.test.ts` is a *source-level* guard rather than a
behavioural one, because the bug it prevents depends on real browser render
timing that happy-dom does not reproduce.
## Where the reasoning lives
- `AGENTS.md` — the rules, in enforceable one-line form, and which test fails
when one is broken. This file holds the reasoning; that one holds the rule.
- `docs/PRODUCT.md` — durable product truth: who it is for, what must never break.
- `docs/TODO.md` — what is *still* queued, each item carrying the reasoning already
settled. Finished work is not kept there; it is in the commit messages.
- `docs/DECISIONS.md` — an index of every significant decision and what it was
chosen over, pointing into the specs for the argument.
- `docs/specs/` — design decisions and the alternatives rejected, one document
per piece of work.
- `docs/plans/` — task-by-task implementation plans.