Lucas WintherandClaude Opus 5.5
50c6e91b00
The new reader app replaces the old UI: Checklist with a rail (focus pills, Next to expire, today's dailies, pinned routines), Timeline in a new and a classic look, Routines, Archive and a Settings area, in a Structured (default) and a Relaxed interface. It follows the approved Round 6 B and Round 7 mockups, corrected screen by screen with the owner. Reader data moves to a v2 store (gacha-tracker:v2:*). Existing v1 data is migrated on first load, a recovery copy is written first, and the v1 keys are never removed, so a rollback finds them unchanged. Redeem codes for Genshin arrive as their own feed. Also: live's urgency ramp, editable per theme; completion and section-complete fireworks; a returning-user tour; the design mockups, specs, plans, reviews and handoff record. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
126 lines
8.5 KiB
Markdown
126 lines
8.5 KiB
Markdown
# Approved redesign — implementation review, 2026-10-16
|
|
|
|
**Status: rejected by the owner for substantial divergence from the approved Round 7 markup.**
|
|
The completion claims below describe the earlier implementation report and are withdrawn as
|
|
evidence of design acceptance. Functional tests and overflow checks did not establish visual or
|
|
interaction fidelity. A faithful markup-to-component correction is still required.
|
|
|
|
The approved [spec](../superpowers/specs/2026-10-16-ui-redesign-design.md) and
|
|
[16-task plan](../superpowers/plans/2026-10-16-ui-redesign.md) are implemented in the working tree.
|
|
Execution was Native. Nothing has been committed, pushed or published.
|
|
|
|
## Delivered
|
|
|
|
Relaxed (Round 7, default) and Structured (Round 6 B rail) share one reader/component tree; Appearance
|
|
switches between them independently of theme, palette and Standard/Compact density. The redesign
|
|
includes Routines and view pins, direct daily ticks, configurable grouping, multi-server progress,
|
|
reset override/revert with accessible clock history, game colours/source credits, custom palettes,
|
|
Automatic/IANA timezone, new and returning onboarding, compact source/new-event/code notices,
|
|
Archive/story statistics, timed Done/Ignore/Undo, local rolling backups and recoverable restore.
|
|
Settings About preserves the colophon; Changelog has its own page and no footer link.
|
|
|
|
The codes feed contains ten real Genshin codes from the pinned Game8 capture. Source fetching remains
|
|
deterministic and shares the existing conduct gates; no additional community requests were needed
|
|
while implementing or reviewing. Unstated expiry stays unknown. Codes newness and per-server
|
|
redemption are separate. Manual refresh checks both feeds and discloses partial code-feed failure.
|
|
|
|
## Verification
|
|
|
|
- **1,587 tests pass**, zero failures, across 74 files. Strict TypeScript and whitespace checks pass.
|
|
- The suite also runs without `public/` or `docs/` in the Docker COPY layout: 1,586 pass, one
|
|
intentional README-only skip, zero failures. No tests depend on a preceding build.
|
|
- Full offline build passes: 209 events across 20 games, ten codes, production JS/CSS/static shell.
|
|
Final shell build `f5b25675010f` was loaded on a fresh origin (port 41880).
|
|
- Chrome checks cover both interfaces, both themes, 1440/390 widths, Standard/Compact, reduced motion
|
|
and an effective 200% CSS viewport. No horizontal page overflow or page errors in that matrix.
|
|
- Browser journeys pass for migration, saved preferred Timeline, events-only setup, selectable empty
|
|
tracking kinds, upcoming placement, isolation from unselected games, extra server with fresh state,
|
|
direct ticks, reset override/revert/history, per-server redemption, Done/Ignore/Undo, unknown-end
|
|
custom creation, real export download/upload/restore, backup preview/restore/Undo, custom palette,
|
|
timezone selection/search, offline reload and the real service-worker update/reload handshake.
|
|
- Two real browser tabs save concurrently with Web Locks explicitly disabled: IndexedDB serialization
|
|
preserves both edits. Unit regressions cover stale progress fields and independent routine pins.
|
|
- A fresh independent reviewer completed whole-change review and focused re-reviews. All important
|
|
findings were fixed with reproductions; final review reports no remaining important findings.
|
|
|
|
## Review fixes and durable decisions
|
|
|
|
Deleted custom definitions no longer reappear from seen snapshots. Progress imports preserve local
|
|
active reset configuration, retain imported clocks as history, and reuse those revisions on repeated
|
|
imports. Opaque extensions survive subsequent transfers without duplicate accumulation. Timeline
|
|
focus applies to routines as well as events; Ending soonest uses one global queue when reset strips
|
|
are off. The browser fallback uses an IndexedDB transaction rather than unlocked whole-envelope
|
|
writes. Account rebase preserves independent routine/pin edits and explicit retirement removal.
|
|
|
|
Original v1 bytes remain available after migration. Restore validates account/clock references and
|
|
saves recovery before replacement. Setup completes before seen-history capture. Source diagnostics
|
|
state what the feed records; absent failure reasons are described as unavailable, never guessed.
|
|
|
|
## Practical limits
|
|
|
|
Backups are browser-local and created while the app is used; they cannot recover storage a reader
|
|
clears. Older completion IDs whose metadata was never retained remain recoverable raw data, but
|
|
cannot produce invented archive descriptions or historical statistics. Codes currently have one
|
|
registered game/source. External fonts have system fallbacks offline. Calendar-date code expiry is
|
|
shown as a date without an invented instant. No accounts, remote sync or push notifications added.
|
|
|
|
## Captures inspected
|
|
|
|
[Relaxed, light, desktop](assets/2026-10-16-redesign/relaxed-light-1440.png) ·
|
|
[Structured, dark, desktop](assets/2026-10-16-redesign/structured-dark-1440.png) ·
|
|
[Structured, dark, phone](assets/2026-10-16-redesign/structured-dark-390.png)
|
|
|
|
Additional transient browser logs and captures are in `/tmp/redesign-browser-*` and
|
|
`/tmp/redesign-final-*`; the facts above and representative images are recorded here for handoff.
|
|
|
|
|
|
## Follow-up: first-visit HTTP/WireGuard startup failure
|
|
|
|
The owner reported the recovery screen on first visit through WireGuard `10.20.20.2`. The precise
|
|
failure reproduced in Chrome at an ordinary HTTP hostname: `crypto.randomUUID` was undefined,
|
|
initial account minting threw, and initialization returned the generic unavailable/saved-data error.
|
|
Localhost-only verification had missed this because localhost is a browser secure context.
|
|
|
|
All reader ID consumers now use 128-bit `crypto.getRandomValues` through `state/reader/ids.ts`.
|
|
Three new regressions failed before the fix and pass afterwards. Browser verification on an actual
|
|
insecure HTTP origin passes both existing-save migration and fresh setup, ordinary edits, adding a
|
|
server, reset override/revert, backups and reload; the original v1 bytes remain unchanged. Focused
|
|
independent review found no important issues. The full suite now passes **1,590 tests** across 75
|
|
files. Typecheck, production rebuild and whitespace checks pass. Rebuilt shell: `9752bd6bf1d2`.
|
|
|
|
The existing preview serves the rebuilt files; hard-refreshing bypasses the browser's cached JS.
|
|
No storage deletion or identity remapping was performed.
|
|
|
|
|
|
## Owner rejection: markup fidelity
|
|
|
|
Direct comparison confirms substantial divergence despite matching outer gutters/panels/fonts:
|
|
|
|
- Round 7's event-entry structure separates event content, a large deadline with supporting text,
|
|
and chevron. Production reused EventRow's prior internal structure and decorated it with CSS.
|
|
- Round 7's Routines uses game bands and aligned columns for progress, cycle/reset, pins and menus.
|
|
Production renders a flattened library with checkbox options and no equivalent table structure.
|
|
- Round 7's settings sidebar includes individual game entries with descriptions, leading into their
|
|
profiles. Production substitutes a generic Your games page and game selector.
|
|
- Round 7's Timeline places routine periods/progress/reset markers on the shared time axis.
|
|
Production appends ordinary routine controls below event timelines and uses textual reset strips.
|
|
- Round 7's Archive story includes interactive per-game outcome breakdowns. Production substitutes
|
|
per-game text totals.
|
|
- The approved header has navigation counts and a dedicated Settings placement. Production uses
|
|
the simpler generic navigation and a different header summary.
|
|
|
|
References: design/mockups/round7/converged.html (final CSS from line 1003 onward and final renderer
|
|
overrides); production ReaderApp.tsx, EventRow.tsx, TimelinePage.tsx, RoutinesPage.tsx,
|
|
SettingsLayout.tsx, GameSettings.tsx, ArchiveStory.tsx. Earlier render functions/CSS in the mockup
|
|
are superseded by later overrides and must not be used in isolation.
|
|
|
|
Root delivery error: the implementation preserved/reused existing presentation components and
|
|
added selected reference styling instead of faithfully translating the approved rendered markup.
|
|
Verification checked functionality and overflow without comparing equivalent reference/production
|
|
screens and interactions. The final review concentrated on data preservation and did not close that
|
|
design-fidelity gap. The owner should not have had to identify it after a completion claim.
|
|
|
|
No implementation edits or data resets were made during this rejection audit. Existing storage and
|
|
HTTP fixes remain in place. Required correction: use the approved rendered markup, hierarchy and
|
|
interactions as the presentation contract, then connect real reader data and compare matching states.
|